Global Broker Regulation & Inquiry App
Broker Search
English

简体中文

繁體中文

English

Pусский

日本語

ภาษาไทย

Tiếng Việt

Bahasa Indonesia

Español

हिन्दी

Filippiiniläinen

Français

Deutsch

Português

Türkçe

한국어

العربية

Download

BlackBull , A3Trading Broker Comparison

Do you want to know which is the better broker between BlackBull and A3Trading ?

In the table below, you can compare the features of BlackBull , A3Trading side by side to determine the best fit for your needs.

  • Rating
  • Basic Information
  • Benchmark
  • Account Information
  • Relevant information
  • Relevant exposure
  • Rating
  • Basic Information
  • Benchmark
  • Account Information
  • Relevant information
  • Relevant exposure
 2 / 3   brokers in total
Rating
Score
Regulatory Status
WikiFX Guarantee
WikiFX Survey
Risk Evaluation
Exposure
Basic Information
Established
Regulatory license
MT4
MT5
Crypto
Deposit and withdrawal method
Benchmark
environment rating
Transaction Speed
Transaction speed rating
Average transaction speed
The highest transaction speed
The highest speed of opening positions
The highest speed of closing position
Slowest transaction speed
The lowest speed of opening positions
The lowest speed of closing position
Trading slippage
Transaction slippage rating
Average slippage
Maximum transaction slippage
Maximum positive slippage
Maximum negative slippage
Transaction Cost
Transaction cost rating
  • Average transaction cost
  • (EURUSD)
  • Average transaction cost
  • (XAUUSD)
Rollover Cost
Rollover cost rating
  • Average transaction cost
  • (EURUSD)
  • Average transaction cost
  • (XAUUSD)
Disconnection results
Software disconnection rating
Average disconnection frequency (times/day)
Reconnection time
Account Information
Accounts
Account name
Products
Deposit REQ
Maximum Leverage
Spread of majors
Forced Liquidation Ratio
Spread Types
Minimum Position
Crypto
Lock postition
Scalping
EA trading
BlackBull
6.48
Regulated
Under guarantee
5-10 years
FMA,FSA
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
ECN STANDARD,ECN PRIME,ECN INSTITUTIONAL
--
US$200
1:500
EURUSD average is 0.2; Gold average is 0.2
0.00
--
0.01
--
A3Trading
1.52
No Regulation
Under guarantee
--
5-10 years
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--

BlackBull BrokersRelevant information

BlackBull 、 A3Trading BrokersRelevant exposure

Which broker is more reliable?

You can determine the reliability and credibility of a broker by checking four factors:

1.Forex broker introduction。

2.Are the transaction costs and expenses of blackbull-markets, a3trading lower?

3.Which broker is safer?

4.Which broker provides better trading platform?

Based on these four factors, we can compare which is reliable. We have broken down the reasons as follows:

Forex broker introduction

blackbull-markets

Risk Warning

Online trading involves significant risk, and you may lose all of your invested capital. It is not suitable for all traders or investors. Please ensure that you understand the risks involved and note that the information contained in this article is for general information purposes only.

General Information

BlackBull Review Summary in 10 Points
Founded 2014
Registered Country/Region Auckland, New Zealand
Regulation FMA
Market Instruments forex, energy, indices, cryptocurrencies, equities and metals
Demo Account Available
Leverage 1:500
EUR/USD Spread From 0.0 pips
Trading Platforms TradingView, MT4, MT5, BlackBull Trader and BlackBull Shares
Minimum deposit $0
Customer Support 24/7 live chat, phone, email

What is BlackBull?

BlackBull is an STP (Straight Through Processing) forex broker that provides online trading services to retail and institutional clients. The company was founded in 2014 and is headquartered in Auckland, New Zealand. BlackBull is regulated by the Financial Markets Authority (FMA) of New Zealand and offers over 26,000 tradable instruments including forex, energy, indices, cryptocurrencies, equities, and metals. The broker provides clients with multiple trading platforms such as MetaTrader 4/5 and various trading tools. The company also provides educational resources to assist traders in their trading journey.

In the following article, we will analyze the characteristics of this broker from various aspects, providing you with simple and organized information. If you are interested, please read on. At the end of the article, we will also briefly make a conclusion so that you can understand the broker's characteristics at a glance.

BlackBull's home page

Pros & Cons

BlackBull appears to be a reliable and well-regulated broker that offers a wide range of trading instruments, platforms, and educational resources. The broker's emphasis on security and transparency, such as offering segregated accounts and holding funds in Tier 1 New Zealand banks, is also a positive aspect.

However, there have been some negative reviews regarding difficulties in withdrawing funds and claims of the broker being a scam, which is a cause for concern.

Pros Cons
• Regulated by FMA • Negative reviews from clients regarding withdrawal issues
• Wide range of tradable instruments • Limited range of payment options
• Demo accounts available
• Multiple trading platforms and tools
• No minimum deposit requirement
• Rich educational resources

It's important to note that this is just a general overview of the pros and cons, and individual experiences may vary.

BlackBull Alternative Brokers

    There are many alternative brokers to BlackBull depending on the specific needs and preferences of the trader. Some popular options include:

    • UFX - provides a user-friendly trading platform and a wide range of educational materials, but there are some concerns about its regulation and customer service.

    • Valutrades - offers competitive spreads and multiple account types, but its product offerings are limited and its customer service could be improved.

    • Z.com Trade - offers low spreads and no deposit or withdrawal fees, but its product offerings are limited and it is only regulated in one jurisdiction.

Ultimately, the best broker for an individual trader will depend on their specific trading style, preferences, and needs.

Is BlackBull Safe or Scam?

It's difficult to make a definitive determination on whether BlackBull is safe or a scam as there is no clear consensus on the matter. While the broker is regulated by the Financial Markets Authority and claims to hold client funds in safe, Tier 1 New Zealand-based banks with segregated accounts, the negative reviews from some clients who report issues with withdrawing their funds raise concerns. It's important for individuals to conduct their own research, carefully evaluate the broker's features and services, and exercise caution when investing their money.

protection measures

Market Instruments

BlackBull offers a diverse range of 26,000+ financial instruments across various asset classes, including forex, energy, indices, cryptocurrencies, equities, and metals. Traders have access to a wide range of currency pairs, including majors, minors, and exotics, and can also trade popular cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Dogecoin. Additionally, the broker provides access to a variety of equity CFDs, including those from major markets like the US, Europe, and Asia. Traders can also trade popular indices like major US and the NASDAQ, as well as energy products like crude oil and natural gas. Lastly, BlackBull provides access to precious metals like gold and silver, which are often used as safe-haven assets during times of market volatility. Therefore, both beginners and experienced traders can find what they want to trade on BlackBull.

Market Instruments

Accounts

Demo Account: BlackBull provides a demo account that allows you to try out the financial markets without the risk of losing money.

Live Account: BlackBull offers a total of 3 account types: ECN Standard, ECN Prime and ECN Institutional. The minimum deposit to open an account is $0, $2,000 and $20,000 respectively. If you are still a beginner and don't want to invest too much money in Forex trading, the ECN Standard account will be the most suitable option for you.

Account Types

Leverage

BlackBull offers a maximum leverage of up to 1:500, which is a generous offer and ideal for professional traders and scalpers. However, since leverage can magnify your profits, it can also result in a loss of capital, especially for inexperienced traders. Therefore, traders must choose the right amount according to their risk tolerance.

Spreads & Commissions

BlackBull spreads and commissions depend on the account type. We can see that the spread starts from 0.8 pips on the ECN Standard account, from 0.1 pips on the ECN Prime account, while only the ECN Institutional account can enjoy raw spreads from 0.0 pips.

There is no commission for the ECN Standard account, a commission of 6 USD per lot for the ECN Prime account and 4 USD per lot for the ECN Institutional account.

Below is a comparison table about spreads and commissions charged by different brokers:

Broker EUR/USD Spread Commission
BlackBull 0.8 pips No commission (Standard)
UFX 2.0 pips No commission
Valutrades 0.5 pips $7 per lot round turn (ECN Pro)
Z.com Trade 0.5 pips No commission (Standard)

Note: Spreads can vary depending on market conditions and volatility.

Trading Platforms

As for the trading platform, BlackBull provides its clients with many options. There are public platforms including TradingView, MetaTrader 4 (MT4), MetaTrader 5 (MT5), BlackBull Trader, and BlackBull Shares.

TradingView is a popular charting and social trading platform that allows traders to connect with other traders, access a wide range of charting tools, and share trading ideas. MT4 and MT5 are well-known platforms in the forex industry, offering advanced charting capabilities, customizable indicators, and algorithmic trading options. BlackBull Trader is a proprietary platform developed by BlackBull that offers advanced charting and trading tools, while BlackBull Shares is a social trading platform that allows clients to automatically copy the trades of experienced traders.

Trading Platforms

Overall, BlackBull's trading platforms are well-designed, user-friendly, and offer a range of advanced features suitable for both beginner and experienced traders. See the trading platform comparison table below:

Broker Trading Platforms
BlackBull TradingView, MT4, MT5, BlackBull Trader, BlackBull Shares
UFX ParagonEx, MT4, UFX Trader
Valutrades MT4, MT5, FIX API Trading, ValuMax
Z.com Trade MT4, MT5, Z.com Trader, Z.com Web Trader

Trading Tools

BlackBull offers Virtual Private Server (VPS) trading to its clients, which is a useful tool for traders who use automated trading strategies or expert advisors. The broker also provides access to other trading tools such as FIX API Trading, which allows traders to connect their own custom software to the BlackBull liquidity pool, as well as Autochartist, which provides market analysis and trading signals. ZuluTrade and MyFxbook are also available for those who want to follow and copy trades of other successful traders. Overall, BlackBull offers a range of trading tools to assist traders in their trading activities.

Deposits & Withdrawals

BlackBull offers its clients multiple options for depositing and withdrawing funds, including bank wire, POLi, and credit/debit card (Visa/MasterCard). The base currencies are USD and NZD.

funding options

No minimum deposit requirement. No fees for deposits and withdrawals. Most deposits are processed instantly, while withdrawals are typically processed within 24 hours.

BlackBull minimum deposit vs other brokers

BlackBull Most other
Minimum Deposit $0 $100

See the deposit & withdrawal fee comparison table below:

Broker Deposit Fee Withdrawal Fee
BlackBull None None
UFX None $50-$100
Valutrades None None
Z.com Trade None None

Note: The above information is subject to change and may vary based on the payment method used. It's always recommended to check with the broker for the most up-to-date and accurate fee information.

To withdraw funds from your account, visit the “My Wallet” tab found on the left-hand side of the portal.

Find the ‘WITHDRAW FUNDS’ tab along the top of this portal page. Within this tab, you will be presented with a 4-step process to request a withdrawal.

Step 1: Select the method by which you want to make a withdrawal. Only methods that you are approved to use will show up as an option to select.

Step 2: Select the wallet from which you want to make a withdrawal. Please note: Each withdrawal request is restricted to one wallet.

Step 3: Specify the amount you want to withdraw.

Step 4: Finally, confirm your request within the Secure Client Area, and the status of your request will change to pending.

Customer Service

    Below are the details about the customer service.

    • Languages: English, Spanish, French, Chinese, German, Portuguese, Italian, Thai language, Korean, Arabic, Vietnamese, etc.

    • Service Hour: 24/7

    • Live chat

    • Email: support@blackbull.com

    • Phone: +64 9 558 5142

    • Address: BlackBull Markets, Level 20, 188 Quay Street, Auckland, 1010

    • Social media: Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, YouTube, Twitter, WhatsApp and Telegram

Customer Service

Overall, BlackBull's customer service is considered reliable and responsive, with various options available for traders to seek assistance.

Pros Cons
• 24/7 live chat support • No option for call back requests
• Multilingual support
• Social media presence for easy communication
• Quick response time to customer inquiries

Note: The information is based on online research and may be subject to change.

Education

A series of educational resources is available at BlackBull, such as webinars, market analysis, and trading videos that cover various topics related to trading.

Educational videos

The educational materials are categorized based on the clients level of experience, with Forex Beginner, Forex Intermediate, and Forex Advanced categories. The educational articles cover a wide range of topics, from the basics of trading to advanced strategies and technical analysis. These resources are designed to help traders develop a better understanding of the markets and improve their trading skills, which can ultimately lead to more successful trades.

Forex Beginner
Forex Intermediate
Forex Advanced

User Exposure on WikiFX

On our website, you can see that some users have reported unable to withdraw and scams. Please be aware and exercise caution when investing. You can check our platform for information before trading. If you find such fraudulent brokers or have been a victim of one, please let us know in the Exposure section, we would appreciate it and our team of experts will do everything possible to solve the problem for you.

User Exposure on WikiFX

Conclusion

Based on the information provided, BlackBull appears to be a well-regulated broker that offers a wide range of tradable instruments across multiple asset classes, as well as a variety of trading platforms and tools. The broker's educational resources and customer service are also noteworthy.

However, there are some negative reviews from clients regarding difficulty with withdrawals and accusations of being a scam platform, so traders should proceed with caution and do their own research before investing with BlackBull.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q 1: Is BlackBull regulated?
A 1: Yes. It is regulated by Financial Markets Authority(FMA) in New Zealand.
Q 2: Does BlackBull offer demo accounts?
A 2: Yes.
Q 3: How much leverage does this broker offer?
A 3: The maximum leverage of BlackBull is 1:500. Please note that this leverage may only be available for some accounts and products. Please consult our articles or the dealer's website for specific information.
Q 4: Does this broker offer copy trading or social trading?
A 4: Yes. BlackBull offers both of them.
Q 5: Does BlackBull offer the industry-standard MT4 & MT5?
A 5: Yes. It supports TradingView, MT4, MT5, BlackBull Trader and BlackBull Shares.
Q 6: What is the minimum deposit for BlackBull?
A 6: There is no minimum initial deposit requirement.
Q 7: Is BlackBull a good broker for beginners?
A 7: Yes. It is a good choice for beginners because it is regulated well and offers various trading instruments with competitive trading conditions on the leading MT4 and MT5 platforms. Also, it offers demo accounts that allow traders to practice trading without risking any real money.
a3trading
Registered in Cyprus
Regulated by No effective regulation at this time
Year(s) of establishment 2-5 years
Trading instruments Currency pairs, indices, commodities, metals, energy, cryptocurrencies, stocks
Minimum Initial Deposit $200
Maximum Leverage 1:200
Minimum spread Information not available
Trading platform own platform
Deposit and withdrawal method VISA, MasterCard, maestro, jiomoney, skrill, bank transfer, neteller, exopayz, paysafecard, paytm, mobikwik, globe pay, fast bank transfer, scardu, etcetera.
Customer Service Email, phone number, address, live chat
Fraud Complaints Exposure Yes

Risk Warning

Online trading involves huge risks and you can lose all your invested capital. It is not suitable for all traders or investors. Please ensure that you understand the risks involved and note that the information contained herein is for general information purposes only.

General information and regulations of A3Trading

A3Trading is an online forex broker registered in Cyprus and currently under no effective regulation.

In the following article, we will analyze the characteristics of this broker from various aspects, providing you with simple and organized information. If you are interested, please read on.

At the end of the article, we will also briefly summarize the main advantages and disadvantages so that you can understand the broker's characteristics at a glance.

Market instruments

Currency pairs, indices, commodities, metals, energy, cryptocurrencies, stocks.....A3Trading allows clients to access a huge range of trading markets. Therefore, both beginners and experienced traders can find what they want to trade on A3Trading.

market instruments

Spreads and commissions for trading with A3Trading

A3Trading does not detail on its website additional trading costs such as spreads, commissions, SWAPs, etc. These costs are very important when calculating profits and losses, and should be considered in aggregate and not chosen in isolation. If you want to trade with A3Trading, we recommend that you take the time to calculate these transaction costs.

Account Types for A3Trading

The minimum initial deposit to open an account at A3Trading is 200 USD. According to the information on its website, there is no demo account or multiple account types. However, there is a no-loss guarantee in the first 5 transactions, and A3Trading claims that the clients can take the profits and A3Trading will cover the possible losses.

In case of absence of any activity for a period of at least three (3) months, the Company reserves the right to apply a fee of US$ 500 thereafter, charged on a quarterly basis. If the Client account is funded by less than US$ 500 and has been inactive for a period of three (3) months, the Company reserves the right to charge a lower amount to cover administrative expenses and close down the account.

Trading platforms offered by A3Trading

The company's trading platform is an in-house developed platform that can be used on computers, tablets and cell phones.

trading platform

Leverage offered by A3Trading

Although some brokers offer leverage up to 1:500 or even 1:1000, the leverage of 1:200 offered by A3Trading is sufficient for the average trader. This is because the more leverage you have, the more risk you take with your money. Even professional traders, let alone novices, should not be tempted to use leverage as large as 1:500.

leverage

Deposit and withdrawal methods and fees

In order to withdraw from your account in A3Trading, you will need to provide a series of documents. The extra fees, minimum amount and processing time are not revealed. The feasible payment methods are: VISA, MasterCard, maestro, jiomoney, skrill, bank transfer, neteller, exopayz, paysafecard, paytm, mobikwik, globe pay, fast bank transfer, scardu, etcetera.

deposit and withdrawal

Educational resources

A series of educational resources is available at A3Trading, such as video lessons, autochartist, daily market review, economic calendar, live rates & charts, real-time trends, etcetera.

educational resources

Customer support of A3Trading

Below are the details about the customer service.

Language(s): English, Arabic, Spanish

Email: customer.service.en@a3trading.com

Phone Number: +441519471242

WhatsApp: +447441427300

Address: Wanakena Ltd, 73 Arch. Makarios III Avenue, Office 301, 1070 Nicosia, Cyprus.

customer support

Users exposures on WikiFX

On our website, you can see that some users have reported scams. Please be aware and exercise caution when investing. You can check our platform for information before trading. If you find such fraudulent brokers or have been a victim of one, please let us know in the Exposure section, we would appreciate it and our team of experts will do everything possible to solve the problem for you.

users' exposure

Advantages and disadvantages of A3Trading

Advantages:

Sufficient information

Educational resources

Many instruments available

Many deposit and withdrawal methods

Disadvantages:

Complaints

No effective regulation

Few information available

No MT4/MT5

No copy trading

Frequent asked questions about A3Trading

Is this broker well regulated?

No, it is currently not effectively regulated and you are advised to be aware of its potential risks.

How much leverage does this broker offer?

The maximum leverage of A3Trading is 1:200. Please note that this leverage may only be available for some accounts and products. Please consult our articles or the dealer's website for specific information.

Are the transaction costs and expenses of blackbull-markets, a3trading lower?

To compare transaction costs across different brokers, our experts analyze the transaction-specific fees (such as spreads) and non-trading fees (such as inactivity fees and payment costs).

To get a comprehensive understanding of how cheap or expensive blackbull-markets and a3trading are, we first considered common fees for standard accounts. On blackbull-markets, the average spread for the EUR/USD currency pair is EURUSD average is 0.2; Gold average is 0.2 pips, while on a3trading the spread is --.

Which broker between blackbull-markets, a3trading is safer?

To determine the safety of our top brokers, our experts will consider many factors. This includes which licenses the broker holds and the credibility of these licenses. We also consider the history of brokers, because long-term brokers are usually more reliable and trustworthy than new brokers.

blackbull-markets is regulated by FMA,FSA. a3trading is regulated by --.

Which broker between blackbull-markets, a3trading provides better trading platform?

When our experts review brokers, they will open their own accounts and trade through the broker's trading platform. This enables them to comprehensively evaluate the quality, ease of use, and function of the platform.

blackbull-markets provides trading platform including ECN STANDARD,ECN PRIME,ECN INSTITUTIONAL and trading variety including --. a3trading provides trading platform including -- and trading variety including --.

Select Country/Region
  • Hong Kong China

  • Taiwan

    tw.wikifx.com

  • United States

    us.wikifx.com

  • South Korea

    kr.wikifx.com

  • United Kingdom

    uk.wikifx.com

  • Japan

    jp.wikifx.com

  • Indonesia

    id.wikifx.com

  • Vietnam

    vn.wikifx.com

  • Australia

    au.wikifx.com

  • Singapore

    sg.wikifx.com

  • Thailand

    th.wikifx.com

  • Cyprus

    cy.wikifx.com

  • Germany

    de.wikifx.com

  • Russia

    ru.wikifx.com

  • Philippines

    ph.wikifx.com

  • New Zealand

    nz.wikifx.com

  • Ukraine

    ua.wikifx.com

  • India

    in.wikifx.com

  • France

    fr.wikifx.com

  • Spain

    es.wikifx.com

  • Portugal

    pt.wikifx.com

  • Malaysia

    my.wikifx.com

  • Nigeria

    ng.wikifx.com

  • Cambodia

    kh.wikifx.com

  • Italy

    it.wikifx.com

  • South Africa

    za.wikifx.com

  • Turkey

    tr.wikifx.com

  • Netherlands

    nl.wikifx.com

  • United Arab Emirates

    ae.wikifx.com

  • Colombia

    co.wikifx.com

  • Argentina

    ar.wikifx.com

  • Belarus

    by.wikifx.com

  • Ecuador

    ec.wikifx.com

  • Egypt

    eg.wikifx.com

  • Kazakhstan

    kz.wikifx.com

  • Morocco

    ma.wikifx.com

  • Mexico

    mx.wikifx.com

  • Peru

    pe.wikifx.com

  • Pakistan

    pk.wikifx.com

  • Tunisia

    tn.wikifx.com

  • Venezuela

    ve.wikifx.com

United States
※ The content of this website abides with local laws and regulations.
You are visiting the WikiFX website. WikiFX Internet and its mobile products are an enterprise information searching tool for global users. When using WikiFX products, users should consciously abide by the relevant laws and regulations of the country and region where they are located.
consumer hotline:006531290538
Official Email:support@wikifx.com;
Mobile Phone Number:234 706 777 7762;61 449895363
Telegram:+60 103342306
Whatsapp:+852-6613 1970;
License or other information error corrections, please send the information to:qawikifx@gmail.com
Cooperation:fxeyevip@gmail.com