Company Summary
No data
WikiFX, as an independent third-party information service platform, is dedicated to providing users with comprehensive and objective broker regulatory information services. WikiFX does not directly engage in any forex trading activities, nor does it offer any form of trading channel recommendations or investment advice. The ratings and evaluations of brokers by WikiFX are based on publicly available objective information and take into account the regulatory policy differences of various countries and regions. Broker ratings and evaluations are the core products of WikiFX, and we firmly oppose any commercial practices that may compromise their objectivity and fairness. We welcome supervision and suggestions from users worldwide. To report any concerns, please contact us: report@wikifx.com
Global Broker Regulation & Inquiry App
Broker Search
English
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Pусский
日本語
ภาษาไทย
Tiếng Việt
Bahasa Indonesia
Español
हिन्दी
Filippiiniläinen
Français
Deutsch
Português
Türkçe
한국어
العربية
是否切换至浏览器默认语言？
切换
A3Trading , FXCL Broker Comparison
Do you want to know which is the better broker between A3Trading and FXCL ?
In the table below, you can compare the features of A3Trading , FXCL side by side to determine the best fit for your needs.
- Rating
- Basic Information
- Benchmark
- Account Information
- Relevant information
- Relevant exposure
- Rating
- Basic Information
- Benchmark
- Account Information
- Relevant information
- Relevant exposure
2 brokers in total
Rating
Score
Regulatory Status
WikiFX Guarantee
WikiFX Survey
Risk Evaluation
Exposure
Official website
Basic Information
Established(years)
Regulatory license
MT4
MT5
Crypto
Deposit and withdrawal method
Benchmark
environment rating
Transaction Speed
Transaction speed rating
Average transaction speed(ms)
The highest transaction speed(ms)
The highest speed of opening positions(ms)
The highest speed of closing position(ms)
Slowest transaction speed(ms)
The lowest speed of opening positions
(ms)
The lowest speed of closing position(ms)
Trading slippage
Transaction slippage rating
Average slippage
Maximum transaction slippage
Maximum positive slippage
Maximum negative slippage
Transaction Cost
Transaction cost rating
- Average transaction cost (USD/Lot)
Rollover Cost
Rollover cost rating
- Average Rollover Cost (USD/Lot)
Disconnection results
Software disconnection rating
Average disconnection frequency (times/day)
Reconnection time(ms)
Account Information
Accounts
Account name
Products
Deposit REQ
Maximum Leverage
Spread of majors
Forced Liquidation Ratio
Spread Types
Minimum Position
Crypto
Lock postition
Scalping
EA trading
Pin on the left
1.54
No Regulation
No guarantee
--
5-10 years
--
Not supported
Not supported
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
Pin on the left
2.21
No Regulation
No guarantee
--
5-10 years
VFSC
Supported
Not supported
BTC,Online bank (Paytrust),PerfectMoney,Local Deposit,Dragonpay,FasaPay
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
ECN Pro account,Volume Cash account,Live Contest account,Interbank Cent account,Interbank Standard account,Start account,Standard account,Cent account
--
--
Forex, metals: up to 1:300 Indices: up to 1:100 Crypto: up to 1:10
from 0.1
80.00
Floating
0.01
--
Score
Regulatory Status
No Regulation
No Regulation
FXCL BrokerRelevant information
A3Trading 、 FXCL BrokerRelevant exposure
Which broker is more reliable?
You can determine the reliability and credibility of a broker by checking four factors:
1.Forex broker introduction。
2.Are the transaction costs and expenses of a3trading, fxcl lower?
3.Which broker is safer?
4.Which broker provides better trading platform?
Based on these four factors, we can compare which is reliable. We have broken down the reasons as follows:
Forex broker introduction
a3trading
| Registered in | Cyprus |
| Regulated by | No effective regulation at this time |
| Year(s) of establishment | 2-5 years |
| Trading instruments | Currency pairs, indices, commodities, metals, energy, cryptocurrencies, stocks |
| Minimum Initial Deposit | $200 |
| Maximum Leverage | 1:200 |
| Minimum spread | Information not available |
| Trading platform | own platform |
| Deposit and withdrawal method | VISA, MasterCard, maestro, jiomoney, skrill, bank transfer, neteller, exopayz, paysafecard, paytm, mobikwik, globe pay, fast bank transfer, scardu, etcetera. |
| Customer Service | Email, phone number, address, live chat |
| Fraud Complaints Exposure | Yes |
Risk Warning
Online trading involves huge risks and you can lose all your invested capital. It is not suitable for all traders or investors. Please ensure that you understand the risks involved and note that the information contained herein is for general information purposes only.
General information and regulations of A3Trading
A3Trading is an online forex broker registered in Cyprus and currently under no effective regulation.
In the following article, we will analyze the characteristics of this broker from various aspects, providing you with simple and organized information. If you are interested, please read on.
At the end of the article, we will also briefly summarize the main advantages and disadvantages so that you can understand the broker's characteristics at a glance.
Market instruments
Currency pairs, indices, commodities, metals, energy, cryptocurrencies, stocks.....A3Trading allows clients to access a huge range of trading markets. Therefore, both beginners and experienced traders can find what they want to trade on A3Trading.
Spreads and commissions for trading with A3Trading
A3Trading does not detail on its website additional trading costs such as spreads, commissions, SWAPs, etc. These costs are very important when calculating profits and losses, and should be considered in aggregate and not chosen in isolation. If you want to trade with A3Trading, we recommend that you take the time to calculate these transaction costs.
Account Types for A3Trading
The minimum initial deposit to open an account at A3Trading is 200 USD. According to the information on its website, there is no demo account or multiple account types. However, there is a no-loss guarantee in the first 5 transactions, and A3Trading claims that the clients can take the profits and A3Trading will cover the possible losses.
In case of absence of any activity for a period of at least three (3) months, the Company reserves the right to apply a fee of US$ 500 thereafter, charged on a quarterly basis. If the Client account is funded by less than US$ 500 and has been inactive for a period of three (3) months, the Company reserves the right to charge a lower amount to cover administrative expenses and close down the account.
Trading platforms offered by A3Trading
The company's trading platform is an in-house developed platform that can be used on computers, tablets and cell phones.
Leverage offered by A3Trading
Although some brokers offer leverage up to 1:500 or even 1:1000, the leverage of 1:200 offered by A3Trading is sufficient for the average trader. This is because the more leverage you have, the more risk you take with your money. Even professional traders, let alone novices, should not be tempted to use leverage as large as 1:500.
Deposit and withdrawal methods and fees
In order to withdraw from your account in A3Trading, you will need to provide a series of documents. The extra fees, minimum amount and processing time are not revealed. The feasible payment methods are: VISA, MasterCard, maestro, jiomoney, skrill, bank transfer, neteller, exopayz, paysafecard, paytm, mobikwik, globe pay, fast bank transfer, scardu, etcetera.
Educational resources
A series of educational resources is available at A3Trading, such as video lessons, autochartist, daily market review, economic calendar, live rates & charts, real-time trends, etcetera.
Customer support of A3Trading
Below are the details about the customer service.
Language(s): English, Arabic, Spanish
Email: customer.service.en@a3trading.com
Phone Number: +441519471242
WhatsApp: +447441427300
Address: Wanakena Ltd, 73 Arch. Makarios III Avenue, Office 301, 1070 Nicosia, Cyprus.
Users exposures on WikiFX
On our website, you can see that some users have reported scams. Please be aware and exercise caution when investing. You can check our platform for information before trading. If you find such fraudulent brokers or have been a victim of one, please let us know in the Exposure section, we would appreciate it and our team of experts will do everything possible to solve the problem for you.
Advantages and disadvantages of A3Trading
Advantages:
Sufficient information
Educational resources
Many instruments available
Many deposit and withdrawal methods
Disadvantages:
Complaints
No effective regulation
Few information available
No MT4/MT5
No copy trading
Frequent asked questions about A3Trading
Is this broker well regulated？
No, it is currently not effectively regulated and you are advised to be aware of its potential risks.
How much leverage does this broker offer？
The maximum leverage of A3Trading is 1:200. Please note that this leverage may only be available for some accounts and products. Please consult our articles or the dealer's website for specific information.
fxcl
| FXCLReview Summary | |
| Founded | 2006 |
| Registered Country/Region | Saint Vincent and the Grenadines |
| Regulation | VFSC |
| Market Instruments | Forex, indices, cryptocurrencies, metals |
| Demo Account | ✔ |
| Leverage | Up to 1:2000 |
| Spread | Low |
| Trading Platform | MT4 Margin WebTrader |
| Min Deposit | $1 |
| Customer Support | Email: support@fxclearing.com |
| Registered office: Plot 54368 Western Commercial Road, The Hub, Itowers, Cbd, Gaborone, Botswana. | |
FXCL Information
FXCL, founded in 2006, is a forex brokerage registered in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines. It is regulated by VFSC. Its current status is revoked. It charges no fees or commissions. Its leverage is up to 1:2000.
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| VFSC regulated | Limited customer support options |
| Wide range of currency pairs and trading instruments | Fixed spreads |
| Low minimum deposit of $1 | No Islamic trading account |
| Eight types of trading accounts to choose from | No MT5 supported |
| Generous leverage up to 1:2000 | No phone number information offered |
| Competitive spreads and low trading fees | |
| MT4 trading platform and webtrader supported | |
| Copy trading available | |
| Demo account available |
Is FXCL Legit?
FXCL is regulated by VFSC in Vanuatu. Its current status is revoked.
| Regulated Country | Regulated Authority | Regulated Entity | License Type | License Number | Current Status |
| Vanuatu | VFSC | FXCL Markets Ltd | Retail Forex License | 14610 | Revoked |
What Can I Trade On FXCL?
FXCL offers traders forex, indices, cryptocurrencies, metals to trade.
| Tradable Instruments | Supported |
| Forex | ✔ |
| Indices | ✔ |
| Metals | ✔ |
| Cryptocurrencies | ✔ |
| Commodities | ❌ |
| Stocks | ❌ |
| Futures | ❌ |
| Options | ❌ |
Account Types
FXCL offers 4 different types of accounts to traders - Start Account, Cent Account, Standard Account, Interbank Cent Account, Interbank Standard Account, ECN Pro Account, Live Contest Account, Volume Cash Account. It also provides demo accounts.
| Account Type | Start Account | Cent Account | Standard Account | Interbank Cent Account | Interbank Standard Account | ECN Pro Account | Live Contest Account | Volume Cash Account |
| Leverage | 1:2000 | 1:1000 | 1:500 | 1:500 | 1:500 | 1:300 | 1:1000 | 1:1000 |
| Spreads | Floating for full spread list | Fixed for fufor full spread list | Fixed for fufor full spread list | Floating starting from 1.1 pip with a 5-digit price feed for full spread list | Floating,starting from 1.1 pip with a 5-digit price feed for full spread list | Floating, starting from 0.1 pip with a 5-digit price feed | Floating for full spread list | Floating for full spread list |
| Position Size | 0.01-1.00 (standard lot) | 0.01-200 (micro lot) | 0.01-2.00 (standard lot) | 0.01-500 (micro lot) | 0.01-5.00 (standard lot) | 0.01-50.00 (standard lot) | 0.01-3.00 (standard lot) | 0.01-3.00 (standard lot) |
| Execution | Market | Instant | Instant/Market | Market | Market | Market | Automatic Market Execution | Automatic Market Execution |
FXCL Fees
FXCL's spreads are as low as 0 pips. FXCL charges low commissions. It charges $3 per lot for forex, metals, indices 0.15% per lot of Crypto when transaction happens in ECN Account and $1.5 per lot for forex, metals when transaction happens in Live Contest Account and Volume Cash Account. The min deposit is $1.
Trading Platform
FXCL's trading platform is MT4 Margin WebTrader, which supports traders on PC, Mac, iPhone and Android.
| Trading Platform | Supported | Available Devices | Suitable for |
| MT4 Margin WebTrader | ✔ | Web, Mobile | Beginner |
| MT5 | ❌ |
Deposit and Withdrawal
FXCL offers a lot of deposit and withdrawal methods.
Deposit
| Method | Processing Time | Fees |
| Online bank (Asiabank) | Instant | N/A |
| Crypto (Alphacoins) | Instant | N/A |
| PerfectMoney | Instant | Low fees |
| Local Deposit | Up to 1 business day | Low fees |
| FasaPay | Quick | FXCL provides full fee coverage for all Fasapay deposits |
| Dragonpay | Instant | N/A |
Withdrawal
| Method | Processing Time | Fees |
| Online bank (Asiabank) | Instant | N/A |
| Crypto (Alphacoins) | Instant | N/A |
| PerfectMoney | Instant | Low fees |
| Local Deposit | Up to 1 business day | Low fees |
| FasaPay | Quick | Low fees |
| Dragonpay | Instant | N/A |
Copy Trading
FXCL's copytrading offers an opportunity to automatically follow good traders and monitor the markets.
Any FXCL client may open an ECN Copy Pro account as a Follower (hereinafter, Follower‘s Account).In order to open an ECN Copy Pro account as a Signal Provider (hereinafter, Provider’s Account), the client should verify the Traders Cabinet first and provide a link to his/her previous trading results on Myfxbook, MQL5 or FX Blue resource or upload an MT4 statement from his/her previous trading account (any account type from any broker is allowed).
Are the transaction costs and expenses of a3trading, fxcl lower?
To compare transaction costs across different brokers, our experts analyze the transaction-specific fees (such as spreads) and non-trading fees (such as inactivity fees and payment costs).
To get a comprehensive understanding of how cheap or expensive a3trading and fxcl are, we first considered common fees for standard accounts. On a3trading, the average spread for the EUR/USD currency pair is -- pips, while on fxcl the spread is from 0.1.
Which broker between a3trading, fxcl is safer?
To determine the safety of our top brokers, our experts will consider many factors. This includes which licenses the broker holds and the credibility of these licenses. We also consider the history of brokers, because long-term brokers are usually more reliable and trustworthy than new brokers.
a3trading is regulated by --. fxcl is regulated by VFSC.
Which broker between a3trading, fxcl provides better trading platform?
When our experts review brokers, they will open their own accounts and trade through the broker's trading platform. This enables them to comprehensively evaluate the quality, ease of use, and function of the platform.
a3trading provides trading platform including -- and trading variety including --. fxcl provides trading platform including ECN Pro account,Volume Cash account,Live Contest account,Interbank Cent account,Interbank Standard account,Start account,Standard account,Cent account and trading variety including --.